Addiction or Dependence?

There’s a fine line between addiction and dependence when it comes to powerful painkillers like opioids. Desperate for relief, patients with legitimate pain can exhibit some of the same behaviors as an addict. 

So, how can you tell the difference?  

First, it’s important to understand that dependence is purely the body’s physical need for a drug to feel well.  

There’s nothing dangerous about this, and it’s very common for many medications, not just painkillers. For instance, a diabetic may be dependent on insulin, but they’re not addicted. 

For those who are dependent on painkillers, suddenly stopping the medication will have negative consequences, including withdrawal symptoms like muscle twitching, vertigo, and nausea. 

Dependence doesn’t cross over into addiction until it becomes a psychological compulsion to seek more drugs. These patients will do anything to get more drugs—including doctor shopping and using multiple pharmacies. 

Here are some common signs to help you recognize an addicted patient:

  • Presents with a poorly defined or difficult-to-diagnose injury
  • Tells you which drugs usually work for them
  • Is seeing you for the first time
  • Appears friendly and talkative
  • Seeks an unusually large number of pills with many refills
  • Calls for refills before the prescription should have been completed with excuses about why they need them
  • Appears to have an unusual depth of knowledge about drugs
  • Refuses examinations, tests, or X-rays
  • Has a vague history of previous physicians and work
  • Becomes increasingly anxious and hostile when questioned
  • Doesn’t keep appointments 

Sources: Fall 2001 Counter Details, “Non-Medical Use of Prescription Drugs” by Thomas Hobbs, MD, PHD, FASAM; http://www.nationalpainfoundation.org/articles/134/addiction-and-chronic-pain.

Add Your Comments


The Pennsylvania Medical Society encourages lively debate, but please behave courteously and responsibly. Comments that include profanity, personal attacks (including language that could potentially identify an individual), or any other inappropriate, offensive, or illegal material will be removed. For more information, please see our Terms of Use. We do not answer legal questions on line. Members seeking general information about laws and regulations affecting medical practice may call our member resource line, (800) 228-7823.

Display name as (optional):

Comments (max 2000 characters):




Comments: 4


Continued --> The Witch burning leftist who beat the drug abuse drum, so hard that they got an incompitent administration to follow it. The raw data is skewed! The numbers are being manipulated and illegal and legal is being counted twice. I know for a fact that the percentage of people who are legally abusing drugs is small (actual patients with doctors). If this is a criminal matter, then why do us honest people have to comply. We are forced to because we need our medicine. They are going to do this with cancer patients. WTF! But, there is not a REMS for tylenol acetominofen, or any of the NSAIDs, but they are equally as dangerous if not 10X worse. These initiatives to restrict pain medications are going to cause a marked rise in alcohol abuse and suicide over the next five years. I would fail the test above, but I shouldn't if my pain had been managed appropriately. The real problem in a societal one. People are narcisists.

In a World of Pain at 6/30/2011 3:55:43 PM


Continued --> How would the average person feel about having their name put into Multiple Pharmaceutical Companies databases, to have sign a contract to their medication, to have to submit to urine drug screens every time you went to your doctors, to have someones receptionist or aid counting your medication. Say you had to do this to get your groceries, or your gas for your car, or what if they did this for alcohol? I think I can justify the need to do this for alcohol. Drunk driving, domestic violence, drunks go to rehabs for abuse too...right. How would you like all your personal information given to ALL the manufacturers of booze, bar owners, state stores, super markets, the FDA, licensure boards, etc. And if you ever had your breathalyzer blow past 0.5 you go to jail. Lets be dramatic...you go to HELL!!! Because that is what you do to a pain patient, when you humiliate them, force them to share their personal information, sign PPAs, then when they have a BAD day, or Week for that matter, which requires some extra medication. You cut them off and send them to the Hell of Pain! Do you know what happens if you require more medication, then your doctor is comfortable to prescribe? You run out early, you tell your doctor, they seem to understand, and write you another prescription, but you can't fill it. The insurance company won't let you. Continued -->

In a World of PAIN at 6/30/2011 3:39:57 PM


Continued - sorry, but this is only 2000 "characters. I just used 70. My concern with the folks who are claiming to be experts, is that they are the "addiction & dependence" folks, not the advocates for the legitimate pain pts. It is so difficult to find caring pain doctors, that everyone who is chronic, has doctor shopped. So what, if I made the decision to see 3 different doctors over the past 3 years. I never saw more then one at a time. The first was too far away, and I had to take off work every month, sometimes every two weeks, so he could feel comfortable. He never had my pain under control (which is important). The second one changed my long-acting medication 4 times in 3 months. Plus after he killed a patient doing this, he admitted that he wasn't really a pain specialist, although the words Pain Management were part of his practices name. The third I am still with, my PCP, but she wants me to see pain specialist, because I am still in pain, and she is uncomfortable with increasing my dosage. Honestly, it is so hard to be a pain patient! And it is going to get impossible to be a pain patient by New Years, when all the Opioid REMS come out. CONTINUED-->

In a World of Pain at 6/30/2011 3:24:25 PM


I am a Critical Care RN, who currently works in Industry developing REMS programs. I am also a chronic pain patient from a failed spinal surgery. I am a husband, a father, a coach, a Christian, and let me say it again, I am in Daily intractible chronic pain. The various Societies and agencies have caused such a stir about drug abuse, that legislation was inacted, and the FDA is now going to fix the problem forcing drug Mfrs to impliment multi-million dollar risk minimization programs. It is difficult being a pain patient. Anyone who doubts that should be hit with a hammer every few hours, everyday, month after month, for years, and see what you think of the bullet points above.

In a World of Pain at 6/30/2011 3:07:13 PM

Last Updated: 8/18/2009
From: 
Email:  
To: 
Email:  
Subject: 
Message: